Showing posts with label Rachel davis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rachel davis. Show all posts

Monday, March 7, 2022

Documenting The Death of Thomas and Rachel (Davis) Port

Thomas Port wrote his will on 22 November 1776. In March 1777, Mrs. Frances Port was issued Letters of Administration by the Court of Ordinary. In his will he left everything to his wife and after her deceased all the Real estate and half of the personal estate be sold and divided equally among the children share and share alike.

However, at probate, the Will and sanity of Thomas Port was questioned and rather than probating the Will the Ordinary Judge Burrows issued a dedimus protestatum directed to F. Britton and S. Nesmith.

dedimus potestatem-- a writ to commission a private person to perform some act in place of a judge (as to examine a witness)

Then, after the issuance of the dedimus potestatem the Judge also granted Frances Port Letters of Testamentary in March 1777.

Frances Port died in 1811 leaving her Will to be executed. The children of Thomas and Frances have left grandchildren to claim a portion of their grandparents estates. 

Her (Frances Port) death resulted in a lawsuit “Joseph Davis and others, Legatees of THOMAS PORT v. The Legatees of Mrs. FRANCES PORT” in an attempt to get the Thomas Port Will probated.

The APPEAL CASE was argued 25th April 1815, by BLANNING for the appellants, and S. MILLER, contra.  

The court case is very interesting but the lawsuit was rejected with the following comments “ The judgment of the Ordinary upon a Will in common form cannot, after 30 years, be controverted by a petition to prove the Will in Solemn form.”

Shortly after the ruling by the Courts, Henry Davis, Jr. executed the following “DEED OF GIFT.”

DEED OF GIFT HENRY DAVIS, JUN'R TO BENJAMIN DAVIS

South Carolina}

Marion District} Know all men by these presents that I Henry Davis, Jun'r in consideration of the Affection which I have for My relation Benjamin Davis do Give & release unto the Said Benjamin Davis all my rights Title Interest & Claim which I could have In that part of Thomas Port Will left to Frances Port During her natural life according to Said Thomas Ports Will to have & to hold all Such rights Title Interest & Estate to him & To his heirs forever In Witnefs whereof I have hereunto Set my Hand & Seal this 30th October 1817. Henry Davis Jun'r

Signed in the presence of

J. B. Godfrey

B. F. Godfrey.

South Carolina}

Marion District} Personally appeared before Me Austin Stone one of the Justices of the peace of said District John B. Godfrey who being duly sworn declareth that he saw Henry Davis Jun'r Sign & deliver the within instrument of writing for the uses and purposes therein contained and that Benj. F. Godfrey was a Subscribing Witnefs To the Same JB Godfrey. Sworn before me this 30th Oct. 1817. Austin Stone J.P.

Marion County

Register of Deeds

Deed Book G, page 57

https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-CSLV-5V1P?i=464&cat=472601


We know from this lawsuit that Letters of Testamentary were issued to Mrs. Frances Port in March 1777. So, on that date we know that Thomas Port was deceased and that he died sometime before March 1777.

We know from Thomas Port Will that he wrote his Last Will and Testament on 22 November 1776.

Thus, we have narrowed Thomas Port death to have occurred between 22 Nov. 1776 and March 1777.

In the lawsuit it is stated that Frances Port died in the year 1811. The Marion County Probate Minutes for this time period makes no mention of her death.

There are 1419 trees on Ancestry that shows Thomas Port death. Of the First 70 listed there are 69 with a death date of 16 Dec 1815 and one with 1780. I will never understand why anyone would spend so much time copying information without verification and without doing the research themselves.

If you would like to read the entire lawsuit it starts on Page 197 of this link

Page 197

https://www.google.com/books/edition/Reports_of_Judicial_Decisions_in_the_Sta/_zMLAAAAYAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Thomas+Port+Davis+Marion+Dist,+SC&pg=PA197&printsec=frontcover

Or page 505 of this link

Page 505

https://www.google.com/books/edition/Reports_of_Judicial_Decisions_in_the_Con/UGstAQAAMAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&bsq=Thomas%20Port

________________________________________________

page 197

https://www.google.com/books/edition/Reports_of_Judicial_Decisions_in_the_Sta/_zMLAAAAYAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&dq=Thomas+Port+Davis+Marion+Dist,+SC&pg=PA197&printsec=frontcover

Page 505

https://www.google.com/books/edition/Reports_of_Judicial_Decisions_in_the_Con/UGstAQAAMAAJ?hl=en&gbpv=1&bsq=Port

SOURCE: Reports of Judicial Decisions, in the State of South Carolina From 1793 to 1816, South Carolina Courts, Joseph Brevard, Vol. III, 41 Broad Street, Charleston, SC, 1840. [Davis, et. Al. v Port]

Wednesday, March 2, 2022

Two Books, Two Families, Two Results: Which is the Correct One?

 Who did Rachel Davis, b. ca 1802, daughter of Samuel Davis and Lucinda R. Munsey married?

In 1929, Harry Alexander Davis wrote a genealogy of the Morgan David Family and published as “The Davis Family (Davies and David) in Wales and America”.

One of the descendants of Morgan David and Catherine Howell, his wife, was a Samuel Davis, b. April 1757 in Marion, Craven District, South Carolina. Samuel Davis married Lucinda R. Munsey about 1783. They had 10 children.

Today’s focus will be on Rachel Davis, the eight child of Samuel Davis and Lucinda R. Munsey.

Harry Alexander Davis said Rachel Davis moved to Tenn. with [her] parents [in] 1818-19 and married there about 1822 James C. Davis, b 1795, Tenn., not related. He was a farmer, both living in 1850 and probably died before 1860, res. Washington Co., Tenn. They had the following children:

        i.    Ruth Davis was born on 17 Sep 1823. She died in Aug 1889 at the age of 65.
         ii.    Baxter Davis was born on 17 Apr 1826. He died in 1828 at the age of 2.
         iii.    Thomas D. Davis, born 5 Dec 1828; died 6 Mar 1893.
         iv.    Lucinda/Lucretia Davis, born 17 Apr 1831; married Benjamin F. Brown, 22 Jul 1855; died 29 Sep 1923.
         v.    Jane A. Davis, born 16 Sep 1834; died 23 Aug 1903.
         vi.    Robert S. "Robb" Davis was born on 16 Jun 1837.
         vii.   William Tilson Davis, born 22 Jul 1841; died 6 May 1928, Erwin, Tennessee.
         viii.  Margaret Davis was born about 1847.

Harry Alexander Davis said that Rachel Davis married James C. Davis, NOT RELATED.  Research in Washington County, Tennessee  shows that James C. Davis married  Rachel Tilson on 12 September 1822.

Rachel Tilson in the Tennessee, U.S., Marriage Records, 1780-2002

Name: Rachel Tilson

Gender: Female

Marriage Date: 12 Sep 1822

Marriage Place: Washington, Tennessee, USA

Spouse: James C Davis

https://www.ancestry.com/discoveryui-content/view/5805489:1169

James C. Davis and Rachel Tilson are in the 1850 Federal CENSUS for Washington County, Tennessee.

Household Member are:

“The Tilson genealogy : from Edmond Tilson at Plymouth, N E , 1638 to 1911:”  by Mercer V. Tilson published in 1911 documents the James C. Davis and Rachel Tilson Family also. On Page 167, Family 1393, the family composition in this book shows the family with the following children:

We have two Books and a Census showing the very same Children to belong to these three  families. 

We know that the same children cannot possible be the children of both couples. Notice how the children names matched those recorded for Rachel in the Harry Davis Book, The Tilson Book and the 1850 Census of Washington County, Tennessee. It’s almost a verbatim list in all cases. Also in the Census Household is Lucinda Davis who is of the correct age to be Lucinda R. Munsey Davis. We have James C. Davis b. 1795 said to be the husband of Rachel Davis and Rachel Tilson but we have only found a marriage event for the marriage of James C. Davis and Rachel Tilson. 

Another mystery is – Who is James C. Davis, b. 21 Mar 1818; d. 1849; listed in the Tilson Book?

So, did James C. Davis married Rachel Tilson or did he marry Rachel Davis?

[Author's Comments] My personal thoughts. Rachel Davis, daughter of Samuel and Lucinda did not marry James C. Davis. Rachel Davis, b. 1802 and Rachel Tilson, b. 12 June 1801 were of the same age. Samuel Davis and Lucinda Munsey did relocate to Washington County, Tennessee about 1818-1819.  Most of the data that Harry Alexander Davis recorded about this family came from Samuel Davis Revolutionary War Pension application (S39406 NC). Harry A. Davis found the 1850 Census with Lucinda Davis, age 90 and realized this could be Rachel Davis Mother. I also believe this is Rachel Davis's mother or James C. Davis' Mother-in-Law. However, I believe Rachel Davis has passed away by 1850 and the wife in the 1850 household is Rachel Tilson.

Rachel Davis daughter of Samuel and Lucinda is my 1st Cousin 5 Times Removed.


__________________________

[1] Harry Alexander Davis, The Davis Family (Davies and David) in Wales and America: genealogy of Morgan David of Pennsylvania (Washington, D.C.: H. A. Davis, 1927), page 130.

https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/18220/

[2] Mercer Verner Tilson, The Tilson Genealogy: from Edmond Tilson at Plymouth, N. E., 1638 to 1911 (Plymouth, England: The Memorial Press, 1911), page 167.

https://www.ancestry.com/search/collections/15162/

[3] 1850 U. S. Census, Washington County, Tennessee, population schedule, Subdivision 4, Washington, Tennessee, Page: 193(Stamped); Line 35, Dwelling 1270, Family 1298, Household of James C. DAVIS; digital images, Ancestry.com (http://www.ancestry.com : viewed 16 February 2022); citing National Archives Microfilm M432 Roll 898.